What exactly the DSA prohibits
The Digital Services Act (DSA) prohibits online platforms from targeting advertisements at minors through profiling based on their personal data when the provider knows with reasonable certainty that the recipient is a minor. The prohibition therefore combines the use of personal profiles with reasonable knowledge that the user is under age.
This does not amount to a ban on every advertisement that a minor might see. Applying this specific prohibition requires distinguishing between showing an advertisement and selecting it through profiling based on personal data in order to target the minor. The available official sources do not classify every advertising format or support the claim that any advertisement seen by a minor violates this rule.
The DSA also prohibits targeting any person with advertising through profiles based on special categories of personal data. The Commission gives sexual orientation, ethnic origin and religious beliefs as examples. This restriction is distinct from the prohibition concerning profiles of minors and is not limited to them.
Advertising transparency is another obligation. On online platforms, advertisements must be clearly identified, and users must receive information about who is presenting them and why they are seeing them. Very large online platforms must also maintain a public repository of advertisements. Providing information about an advertisement does not make prohibited targeting permissible.
What reasonable certainty means
The rule on advertising targeted at minors applies when the provider knows with reasonable certainty that the recipient is a minor and uses profiles based on the recipient’s personal data to present advertisements to them. The official sources describe this knowledge threshold but do not specify how to determine it or whether it requires knowing the user’s exact age.
The official sources cited do not specify a universal certainty percentage or a single technical method for determining age. Nor do the available passages establish a general obligation to request identity documents or collect additional data to verify it. This advertising restriction should therefore not be confused with a universal age-checking system.
To examine a practice, it is useful to separate two questions: are profiles based on personal data being used to target the advertisement, and does the provider know with reasonable certainty that the recipient is a minor? The sources do not support the conclusion that every inference drawn from usage patterns automatically triggers the prohibition. The assessment depends on the facts of each service.
Privacy, safety and understandable terms
Providers of online platforms accessible to minors must take appropriate measures to ensure a high level of privacy, safety and protection for minors on the service. This obligation sets an objective, but the cited sources do not prescribe a single technical solution or a closed list of identical features for every platform.
The Commission says that online platforms used by minors should design their interfaces to provide the highest level of privacy, safety and protection for them, or participate in codes of conduct intended to protect them. They should also take account of available good practices and guidance, such as the European strategy for a better internet for children, known as BIK+. These guidelines are not a uniform technical specification.
For intermediary services primarily directed at minors or primarily used by them, the DSA requires providers to make efforts to ensure that their terms and conditions are easily understandable to that group. The obligation concerns the comprehensibility of the terms; the available sources do not establish that every service must explain each item of data collected in a specific format.
Advertising and transparency: separate obligations
A practical distinction is to separate who can see an advertisement from how its recipient is selected. The specific prohibition concerns advertisements targeted at minors through profiles based on their personal data when the provider knows with reasonable certainty that the user is a minor. The sources do not support the conclusion that all contextual advertising is prohibited, and they do not classify every format.
The European Commission says that advertisements on online platforms must be clearly identified and that users must have information about who is presenting them and why they are seeing them. Very large online platforms must also maintain a public repository of advertisements. Identifying an advertisement does not authorize a targeting method that is prohibited.
The DSA prohibits providers of online platforms from targeting advertisements through profiles based on special categories of personal data, such as sexual orientation, ethnic origin or religious beliefs. This prohibition is distinct from the one concerning profiles of minors. The Commission explains that the DSA complements the data-processing conditions established by the GDPR.
Which services these obligations apply to
The DSA applies to intermediaries and online platforms in the European Union, such as online marketplaces, social networks, content-sharing platforms and app stores. The Commission describes a proportional approach: obligations depend on a service’s role, size and impact, and small and micro-enterprises are exempt from some rules that could be more burdensome for them.
General child-protection obligations should be distinguished from the additional obligations for very large online platforms and search engines. The latter must assess and mitigate systemic risks, including risks related to the protection of minors and their physical and mental well-being. The Commission supervises services designated as very large; national authorities supervise other services within the DSA framework.
When analysing a service, it is useful to check separately whether it is an online platform accessible to minors, whether it is an intermediary service primarily directed at or primarily used by minors, and whether it is designated as a very large platform or search engine. These are different conditions: accessibility, primary audience and size are not interchangeable categories.
How to assess an advertising practice
To assess a practice, separate the reach of the advertisement from the method used to select its recipient. If an advertisement is targeted at a minor through profiles based on their personal data and the provider knows with reasonable certainty that they are a minor, the prohibition described applies. If those profiles are not used, the cited sources do not justify claiming that the advertisement is prohibited under this particular rule.
A practical review can follow this sequence: first, identify whether the service is an online platform accessible to minors; then check whether it takes appropriate privacy, safety and protection measures; next, determine whether it is an intermediary service primarily directed at or primarily used by minors, in order to assess the comprehensibility of its terms; finally, review the identification of advertisements and the information provided about them separately.
The DSA and the GDPR can apply simultaneously to the processing of personal data for advertising. The Commission explains that the DSA complements the GDPR’s rules and adds specific limits: it restricts advertising profiles based on special categories of data and prohibits presenting advertisements targeted through profiles when the provider knows with reasonable certainty that the user is a minor. The rules complement one another, but they do not serve identical purposes.