Two rights with different purposes
The GDPR grants several rights concerning personal data, including erasure and data portability. Erasure lets people ask for data to be deleted in specified circumstances; portability makes it easier to obtain certain data for reuse or transmission to another controller. They are not two ways of achieving the same result.
Requesting portability does not delete the data from the service that holds it. Conversely, asking for erasure does not mean receiving a copy to transfer elsewhere. The response depends on the applicable requirements and the circumstances of the processing; some rights do not apply in every situation.
When you can request erasure
Article 17 allows a person to ask an organisation to erase personal data when one of the specified grounds applies. These include cases where the data are no longer needed for the purpose for which they were collected, the processing is unlawful, consent is withdrawn and there is no other legal basis, or an objection to the processing is upheld.
Erasure may also be required when a legal obligation requires the data to be deleted, or when they were collected in connection with the offer of information society services to a child. If data have been made public and erasure is warranted, the controller must take reasonable steps to inform other controllers processing the data about the request concerning links or copies.
Limits and examples
The right is not absolute. It may not apply where processing is necessary for freedom of expression and information, compliance with a legal obligation or the performance of a task in the public interest, public health reasons, certain archiving or research purposes, or the establishment, exercise or defence of legal claims.
For example, someone may ask a social network to remove the data in their account. However, if a law requires an organisation to retain certain data, it may not be able to erase them while that obligation remains in force. The European Commission notes that, in such a case, it may be relevant to request restriction of processing, which allows the data to be retained while limiting other uses.
What data portability covers
Data portability lets people obtain personal data in a structured, commonly used and machine-readable format so they can reuse them in another context. They can also request direct transmission to another controller where this is technically feasible.
This right applies only when three conditions are met together: the processing is based on consent or a contract; it is carried out by automated means; and the data were provided by the person. The European Data Protection Board’s guidance also includes data observed from a person’s behaviour, such as data obtained through connected accessories. It does not, however, include data that the organisation itself creates based on that information.
Formats and transmission
The European Data Protection Board’s guidance names XML, JSON and CSV as common formats that meet portability criteria, and states that a PDF is not sufficient. It also says that metadata must be provided so the data can be used on another platform.
Direct transmission to another controller depends on whether it is technically possible. If it is not, the person can request their data in a reusable format. The right applies only insofar as it does not adversely affect the rights and freedoms of other people.
Deadlines and how to make a request
To exercise these rights, you can contact the company or organisation processing your data, known as the controller. If it has a data protection officer, you can also send the request to that person. State clearly whether you are requesting erasure or portability and identify the data or processing concerned.
As a general rule, the controller must respond within one month. If the request is complex and requires more time, the controller may extend the deadline by up to two additional months, but must notify you of the extension within the first month. If there are reasonable doubts about your identity, the controller may ask for additional information to confirm it.
You can submit your request through a channel that allows you to communicate with the organisation, and keep a copy of what you send. It is also useful to retain the response. If the organisation will not comply, it must explain why within the first month and inform you of the possibility of lodging a complaint with the data protection authority and seeking a judicial remedy.
Practical comparison
The table summarises the main differences. In both cases, the right is exercised with the controller processing the data, but the conditions and requested outcome are different.
| Aspect | Erasure | Data portability |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Request deletion of data when a specified ground applies | Obtain certain data for reuse or transmission |
| Key conditions | A ground for erasure must apply; exceptions exist | Consent or contract, automated processing and data provided by the person |
| Possible outcome | Deletion, unless an exception applies | Provision in a structured, machine-readable format |
| Transmission to another controller | Not the purpose of this right | Can be requested if technically feasible |
| Limits | Among others, legal obligations, freedom of expression or legal claims | Does not apply insofar as it affects the rights and freedoms of other people |
If the response does not resolve the issue
If you believe your rights have not been respected, you can lodge a complaint with the national data protection authority. The European Commission says that the authority investigates and informs you of the progress or outcome of the complaint within three months; this does not necessarily mean the investigation must be completed within that period.
You can also take legal action against the organisation if you believe it has infringed your rights. If you are dissatisfied with the authority’s handling of the matter, or receive no information about progress or outcome within three months, the European Commission says you can take the authority to court. According to the Commission, compensation may be claimed if a breach of the rules has caused you material or non-material damage.
Before lodging a complaint, keep the request, the response and related communications. This will help you explain which right you exercised and what response you received, without confusing a request for deletion with a request to obtain or transfer data.